The Fed Wants to "Shock People." Insurers Get Paid If It Does.
By Bill Spencer ·
Yesterday, the S&P 500 closed below its 200-day moving average for the first time since April 7th.
Then this morning, Fed Governor Christopher Waller told CNBC that a half-point rate hike is probably necessary at the Fed's December 8-9 meeting.
His words: "You might need to, like, shock people."
Even Nvidia couldn't steady things. Last night, it reported revenue of $115.84 billion, more than $6 billion above estimates. The stock jumped in early trading this morning… then turned lower.
So the question I keep hearing is: "Does any part of this market actually like higher rates?"
One does. And our "True Market" indicators have been pointing at it for weeks.

As of Tuesday's close, Insurance (INSU), which houses 109 stocks, ranks #4 out of the 45 sectors we track, ranked by relative strength.
Back on June 10th, it was #34. It has ranked in our top five every trading day since October 22nd.
Above the Line
The 200-day moving average is the long-term trend line a lot of traders watch. Here's who is above it and who isn't:

The S&P 500 closed Tuesday 0.1% below its 200-day average. The Nasdaq is 3.3% below its own. And Nvidia (NVDA) is 23.7% below.
The typical insurance stock? It's 6.2% above its 200-day. And 71 of the 109 stocks in the sector are above theirs.
Like we say, "You see it in the price before you see it in the news."
So why would the big money pile into insurers right as the Fed gets more aggressive?…
How Insurers Get Paid When Rates Rise
Insurers collect premiums up front. They pay claims months, sometimes years, later.
In the meantime, they invest that cash, mostly in high-grade bonds. The industry calls it "float."
When rates rise, maturing bonds and fresh premiums get reinvested at higher yields.
On Chubb's (CB) October 21st earnings call, CEO Evan Greenberg put it plainly: "our current and future operating income benefits from a rising interest rate environment."
That fits what the price action already told us.
What the Insurance Participation Chart Says

The sector's Bullish Percent Index (BPI) is the percentage of its stocks on bullish Buy signals. That means it’s a gauge of how much participation there is in a rally.
It stands at 60.55%. That means 66 of the 109 insurance stocks are trading above key levels of resistance on their price charts.
And the chart is in a column of X's while on a Buy signal. That's Bull Confirmed, meaning Demand (the bulls) controls the short-term and the longer-term trend.
On October 29th, I showed you the insurance trade in "Alphabet Lost $500 Billion. The Big Money Had Already Moved On." Since the close before that article, the SPDR S&P Insurance ETF (KIE) is up +4.5% (the S&P 500 fell 5.2% over the same period).
Want to see where all 45 sectors rank every day, before the headlines catch up? That's what Sector Prophets Pro members get, plus sector BPI alerts and live mentoring sessions. See how Sector Prophets Pro works.
How I'd Play It
For broad exposure, our platform's top insurance ETF is the iShares U.S. Insurance ETF (IAK).
It's heavily weighted in property and casualty insurers. Its two biggest holdings, Progressive and Chubb, make up about 27% of the fund. Since the S&P 500's October 6th record close, IAK is up +10.0% (the S&P 500 fell 6.1% over the same period).
But for the strongest exposure, I'd go stock by stock.
American Integrity Insurance Group (AII) is a Tampa-based home insurer, founded in 2006 to serve Florida after the 2004 hurricanes. It went public on the NYSE in May 2025.
It's stronger than 98% of the stocks in the Insurance sector.

The stock is up +39.1% this year (the S&P 500 is up +7.2% over the same period).
On November 10th, the company reported third-quarter net income of $28.4 million, or $1.44 per share.
Policies in force rose 18.6% from a year earlier. Book value per share rose 23.7%.
And net investment income, the float at work, rose to $8.4 million from $6.9 million.
The risk: this is a Florida home insurer, so one bad hurricane can hit results hard. Higher rates also lower the market value of bonds insurers already own. And the stock can swing: on November 11th, it opened at $32.21, then closed at $29.41.
It closed Tuesday at $28.98, 1.8% below its October 26th closing high of $29.52, its best close since going public.
A move back to its November 11th intraday high of $32.21 would mean a gain of +11%.
And I ran a Fibonacci Extension study (not shown) measuring the stock's move from its September 30th intraday low of $24.15 to its November 11th intraday high of $32.21. That study gives me a minimum price objective of approximately $40.27 per share.
From $28.98, a move to $40.27 would represent a potential upside of roughly +39%.
The S&P 500 just broke its long-term trend line.
Insurance is trading well above its own.
Stay tuned!
Big Bill Spencer
Sector Edge